Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia- A book review

Jan 11, 20217 comments

Disclaimer: Elgee Writes is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost to you.

As the first read of the year, I picked up Mexican Gothic – a book I have been wanting to read for a while now. Read on my book review of Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia to see how it worked for me.

Have you read Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia? What's your first read of 2021? What's your favorite horror book set in the 1950s? Click To Tweet

About Mexican Gothic

Cover Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Book Name: Mexican Gothic

Author: Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Genre: Fiction – Fantasy, paranormal, horror

Characters: Noemí Taboada, Catalina, Virgil, Florence, Francis and Howard Doyle

Setting: Mexico

Plot Summary of Mexican Gothic

When her father sends Noemí Taboada to High Palace in the Mexican countryside as a response to her newly-wed cousin’s alarming letters about her husband, she is not enthused.

Noemi, a flighty, party loving 23 year old in the 1950s, who wants to get her father’s approval to her dreams of attending university considers this as an opportunity to win him over, as well as to help her dear cousin Catalina.

When she first arrives at the ancient, crumbling mansion, the welcome from her cousin’s husband Virgil Doyle and his family is less than lukewarm. She finds out that Catalina’s health, physically and mentally is fragile and the Doyles’ family doctor doesn’t seem helpful.

With frosty and unhelpful relatives and a house that squeaks and creaks at every turn, Noemi begins to believe that her cousin was correct. And it was up to her to save herself and Catalina.

Was she able to do that? What is it about the house that does not let them escape form the rest of the story in Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Book review of Mexican Gothic

Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia is a well written gothic fantasy thriller, leaning more towards fantasy than the thriller part. I had a huge expectations and I was left with a mixed feeling about it.

I really liked the first few pages of the book, but it took me more than fifty pages to actually get into the story. But until the last fifty pages or so, it moves really slow.

I love reading about dysfunctional families and the Doyles were definitely one of them. An aged patriarch who believes in “natural selection” and eugenics, a creepy, manipulative son, a controlling and matronly aunt and shy young man who is interested in fungus definitely wins the title.

If you like atmospheric horror like the Haunted of hill house, you are in for a treat. But being more of a “The Shining” fan, I was drifting off mentally often. Of course, it is definitely a “me” thing.

Apart from Noemi, Francis is the only other character to catch my attention and has some sort of character arc. But I am definitely not sold on their romance and strongly believe that they would be better of as friends. (I dunno why all stories have to have a romantic angle!)

What worked for me

  • I liked Noemi and her character development from a socialite who was a brat to a person to a matured young lady was interesting.
  • It was interesting to read about Marta and her stories about her ancestors and their culture. I wanted hear more from her about the colonialism and its effect on its Mexican subjects.
  • The whole creepy vibe of the mansion and the family is very well done. I felt sorry for the ladies for having stuck into the mess in the first place, even before realizing what it was about.

What may have been better

  • Mexican Gothic is definitely a slow burn, it takes about 50% of the book to garner the speed.
  • The mystery part is thinly veiled. If you paid close attention, you would stumble upon it quite easily and pretty early on.

Content warning

Sexual assault(s), incest, murder, cannibalism, death of children, stillbirth, miscarriage, death of parent.

Bottom line

Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia is a must read for the fans of The Haunted hill house and other haunted house mysteries. But if you are someone like me, who wants more action than just the eerie atmosphere, you might find your attention wavering.

Similar book reviews

Pin me!

Book review Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia Pinterest

Let’s chat

Have you read Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia? Share with me about your favorite haunted house books? What are your recommendations for horror books set in the 1950s? Let us talk.

Hello there!

Gayathri loves reading, recommending books and talking about bookish things in real life. Her blog is just an extension of that habit. When she is not reading books or creating online content, she freelances as a beta reader. She lives currently in Dubai.Head over to meet me

Categories

Like what I do?

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com

Grab the button

Grab button for Comment 4 Comment Challenge 2021
<div class="Comment-4-Comment-Challenge-2021-button" style="width: 150px; margin: 0 auto;"> <a href="http://elgeewrites.com/" rel="nofollow"> <img src="https://elgeewrites.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/C4CC21.png" alt="Comment 4 Comment Challenge 2021" width="250" height="250" /> </a> </div>

7 Comments

  1. Heather @ RandomRedheadedRamblings

    I’m hoping to read this in the next few months, I’m probably more of a Shining type of girl but I’ll see how I get on.

    Reply
    • Gayathri

      Yes, keep me updated. I want to know your thoughts too.

      Reply
  2. Iza

    Great review, Gayathri ! I’ve been hesitating whether to read this or not, I guess I’ll have to borrow it at the library to make my mind up definitely 🙂 I usually adore mushrooms but I have a feeling I won’t like those, lol !

    Reply
    • Gayathri

      Yes, let me know how it goes for you!

      Reply
  3. Karen Siddall

    I have this one on my TBR pile but have been putting it off in favor of other things. I’ll hold on to it until I have a slow period I believe.

    Reply
    • Gayathri

      Yes, I did the same for a while too.

      Reply
  4. Jenny @ Reading the End

    I definitely wasn’t into the romance angle, but I loved this book as a Gothic novel. It felt very classic, like a throwback to those Mary Stewart-type Gothic novels from the 1960s or whenever it was that they were so popular, but much more aware of issues of class and race and gender than those books were (of course). I was SO creeped out by the mushrooms!!

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: